Which One Are You: Ideologue or Pragmatist?

Share this & earn $10
PragerU
Published at : 20 Dec 2020
863547 views
17552
1181

When it comes to politics, do you have an ideology? Or are you a pragmatist? What's the difference? Is one better than the other? Jonah Goldberg, Senior Editor for National Review, explains why ideology matters, and why "pragmatism" may not mean exactly what you think it does.
Donate today to PragerU! http://l.prageru.com/2ylo1Yt

Joining PragerU is free! Sign up now to get all our videos as soon as they're released. http://prageru.com/signup

Download Pragerpedia on your iPhone or Android! Thousands of sources and facts at your fingertips.

iPhone: http://l.prageru.com/2dlsnbG
Android: http://l.prageru.com/2dlsS5e

Join Prager United to get new swag every quarter, exclusive early access to our videos, and an annual TownHall phone call with Dennis Prager! http://l.prageru.com/2c9n6ys

Join PragerU's text list to have these videos, free merchandise giveaways and breaking announcements sent directly to your phone! https://optin.mobiniti.com/prageru

Do you shop on Amazon? Click https://smile.amazon.com and a percentage of every Amazon purchase will be donated to PragerU. Same great products. Same low price. Shopping made meaningful.

VISIT PragerU! https://www.prageru.com

FOLLOW us!
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/prageru
Twitter: https://twitter.com/prageru
Instagram: https://instagram.com/prageru/
PragerU is on Snapchat!

JOIN PragerFORCE!

For Students: http://l.prageru.com/29SgPaX
JOIN our Educators Network! http://l.prageru.com/2c8vsff

Script:

One of the staple arguments of American liberals, from Presidents Woodrow Wilson to Bill Clinton, from education reformer John Dewey to New York Times columnist Tom Friedman is that they "don’t believe in labels." Liberals are "pragmatists," and "realists," and "empiricists." They only care about "what works." Conservatives, meanwhile, are "ideologues" – or extremists, or dogmatists, or just plain lunatics – who are blinded by ideology.

Here’s what President Barack Obama said on the subject: "What is required is a new declaration of independence, not just in our nation, but in our own lives from ideology and small thinking, prejudice and bigotry."

Did you catch that? If you have an ideology, you belong amongst the bigots and the mentally confused.

Once you start paying attention, you’ll hear variations on this claim all over the place. In truth, it is a very old technique, pioneered by none other than Napoleon Bonaparte, who sought to demonize his critics as mesmerized theorists enthralled to an ideology while he put the needs of the nation above all considerations.

Marx picked up the technique, arguing that only the people who agreed with him were free of mind-warping ideology. The desirability and inevitability of socialism was to them a scientific fact, and therefore anyone who disagrees with scientific fact must be, in effect, brainwashed.

In the 20th Century, the American Progressives offered their own version of the same idea. They created a whole philosophical school -- Pragmatism -- which as a matter of principle rejected philosophical principles. William James, the most important founder of Pragmatism argued that we should measure ideas not by whether they are right or wrong, but by whether they "work." Ideas are right if they have "cash value," according to James.

Herbert Croly, the founder of the New Republic, responding to the criticism that his liberal magazine was too pro-Mussolini -- whose ideas seemed to be working in Italy at the time -- said it well: "If there are any abstract liberal principles, we do not know how to formulate them. Nor if they are formulated by others do we recognize their authority. Liberalism, as we understand it, is an activity."

Contemporary American liberalism has inherited this pose. It is certain it knows "what works" – liberalism! And what is liberalism? What liberals do! It’s an activity! -- and they denigrate opposing viewpoints not as competing ideas or positions, but as the products of a warped, "ideological" worldview.

How often do you hear people say, "I don’t believe in labels?” Whether its liberal politicians, TV news anchors, columnists, cable news hosts or your brother-in-law, Harry, the line always goes something like this: "Why can’t we move beyond these partisan labels? Why can’t we get beyond this philosophical divide and get to the hard work of dealing with the problems facing the American people?"

Warning: People only they say these things when they want you to shut up and get with their program.

What you never hear them say is: "We need to move beyond these partisan labels, we need to get beyond the philosophical divide and for that reason I’m going to abandon all of my principles and agree with you."

For the complete script, visit https://www.prageru.com/videos/which-one-are-you-ideologue-or-pragmatist
Dennis PragerPragerUPrager University

ROBLOX AIRPLANE 4...

ROBLOX AIRPLANE 4...

Trailer de The Olsen Gang in Deep Trouble — Olsenbanden På Dybt Vand (HD)

Trailer de The Olsen Gang in Deep Trouble — Olsenbanden På Dybt Vand (HD)

Doctors Diagnose The Injuries From Home Alone 2

Doctors Diagnose The Injuries From Home Alone 2

Excellent place for nature lovers | Vanghat Lodge | The wildlife lodge Corbett | wilderness paradise

Excellent place for nature lovers | Vanghat Lodge | The wildlife lodge Corbett | wilderness paradise

12 Strange Things You Only See in India

12 Strange Things You Only See in India

박진영 (J.Y. Park) - When We Disco (Duet with 선미) | 1시간 가사 (Lyrics)

박진영 (J.Y. Park) - When We Disco (Duet with 선미) | 1시간 가사 (Lyrics)

World's Most Expensive Saloon | Lagonda Taraf

World's Most Expensive Saloon | Lagonda Taraf

Investigators Say Hackers Are Targeting Hospitals In Ransomware Attacks

Investigators Say Hackers Are Targeting Hospitals In Ransomware Attacks

Woman shares footage of assault by street harasser at Paris cafe

Woman shares footage of assault by street harasser at Paris cafe

Creative Talented People 😍 Most Amazing Art Drawing Video #89 👍 Satisfying Lettering Calligraphy

Creative Talented People 😍 Most Amazing Art Drawing Video #89 👍 Satisfying Lettering Calligraphy

12 Most Mysterious Ancient Discoveries Scientists Still Can't Explain

12 Most Mysterious Ancient Discoveries Scientists Still Can't Explain

Partly Cloudy Pixar Short Film

Partly Cloudy Pixar Short Film

'Little While' - Chris Garneau (Dir. Samuel Stonefield)

'Little While' - Chris Garneau (Dir. Samuel Stonefield)

Vans Europe Presents: Cracow DIY Adventure | Skate | VANS

Vans Europe Presents: Cracow DIY Adventure | Skate | VANS

11 Sales Training Basics Beginners MUST Master

11 Sales Training Basics Beginners MUST Master

Bangladesh Army Sainik Job Circular 2021

Bangladesh Army Sainik Job Circular 2021

Busing on the Lookout (BOTL) Training Video

Busing on the Lookout (BOTL) Training Video

HOW TO MAKE A STURDY JACK STAND FOR YOUR CAR. VERY CHEAP DIY

HOW TO MAKE A STURDY JACK STAND FOR YOUR CAR. VERY CHEAP DIY

Using ‘PERHAPS’ To Speak Polite And Soft English | English Communication Skills | Formal English

Using ‘PERHAPS’ To Speak Polite And Soft English | English Communication Skills | Formal English

Introduction to 'THE VITAL NERVES' book by John Gibbons (Bodymaster)

Introduction to 'THE VITAL NERVES' book by John Gibbons (Bodymaster)

Real Time with Bill Maher: Citizens United Makes $1M Seem Quaint (HBO)

Real Time with Bill Maher: Citizens United Makes $1M Seem Quaint (HBO)

Mysterious Vipers get Awesome Indoor Habitats!

Mysterious Vipers get Awesome Indoor Habitats!

Bastille - Pompeii

Bastille - Pompeii

小柳ゆき - あなたのキスを数えましょう〜You were mine〜 + Sunrise (Live)

小柳ゆき - あなたのキスを数えましょう〜You were mine〜 + Sunrise (Live)

Mowgs - Different [Music Video] | GRM Daily

Mowgs - Different [Music Video] | GRM Daily

Police Ask A Homeowner For His Identification For Walking Around His Home Looking Suspicious

Police Ask A Homeowner For His Identification For Walking Around His Home Looking Suspicious

Spice Dawn: Cast-Pink Warmer of the Month Feb 2021

Spice Dawn: Cast-Pink Warmer of the Month Feb 2021

Learning Thursdays: Year in Ethics: Mandated Reporting

Learning Thursdays: Year in Ethics: Mandated Reporting

What do Polish girls in Warsaw & Krakow think of foreign guys?

What do Polish girls in Warsaw & Krakow think of foreign guys?

Is this FINALLY the cheap FPV goggle WE WANT? SJ-RG01 FPV goggle review

Is this FINALLY the cheap FPV goggle WE WANT? SJ-RG01 FPV goggle review

Dorothy Kirsten -- All The Things You Are (Very Warm For May) (VintageMusic.es)

Dorothy Kirsten -- All The Things You Are (Very Warm For May) (VintageMusic.es)

Donald Trump: A Man of Characters: The Daily Show

Donald Trump: A Man of Characters: The Daily Show

You are Made Up of Nothingness

You are Made Up of Nothingness

DO YOU WANT THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF JANNAH?

DO YOU WANT THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF JANNAH?

NEW MAKEUP @ THE DRUGSTORE

NEW MAKEUP @ THE DRUGSTORE

New Moleskine Notebook: Expanded Version!!

New Moleskine Notebook: Expanded Version!!

How To Apply For A Job Online (And ACTUALLY Get An Interview)

How To Apply For A Job Online (And ACTUALLY Get An Interview)

Tend to Vs Intend to - Common Mistake

Tend to Vs Intend to - Common Mistake

Seal "Black Tie" Finally Rescued

Seal "Black Tie" Finally Rescued

Top 10 Mysteries That Will Probably NEVER Be Solved

Top 10 Mysteries That Will Probably NEVER Be Solved

Nastya and dad celebrate their birthdays

Nastya and dad celebrate their birthdays

InMe - Myths and Photographs [Daydream Anonymous (2007)]

InMe - Myths and Photographs [Daydream Anonymous (2007)]

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo - The Difference - HD

Lionel Messi vs Cristiano Ronaldo - The Difference - HD

We are searching for Java Developers - with subtitles

We are searching for Java Developers - with subtitles

This College Student Was Kicked Off the Student Senate for Sharing His Catholic Beliefs

This College Student Was Kicked Off the Student Senate for Sharing His Catholic Beliefs

How Individuals are Taking Ownership of their Digital Identity

How Individuals are Taking Ownership of their Digital Identity

IMPACT - Jésus je te suivrai

IMPACT - Jésus je te suivrai

Weston McKennie is 'like gold' to Andrea Pirlo at Juventus - Gab Marcotti | ESPN FC

Weston McKennie is 'like gold' to Andrea Pirlo at Juventus - Gab Marcotti | ESPN FC

SEPHIROTH JOINS SMASH: Here is What That Means... (The Game Awards Analysis)

SEPHIROTH JOINS SMASH: Here is What That Means... (The Game Awards Analysis)